Optical Properties of Nannochloropsis oculata During Progressive Nitrogen Starvation
The marine microalgae Nannochloropsis oculata is known to accumulate lipids, mainly in the form of triglycerides making them an attractive species for renewable biodiesel production. Lipid productivity can be increased by nitrogen starvation of cells causing them to progressively decrease their replication rate in favor of accumulating lipids (up to 70% in dry weight). In addition to nitrogen starvation, recent studies have shown light availability in photobioreactors (PBR) and light received per cell to be important factors in the lipid productivity of the microalgae. These depend on the incident photon flux density, microalgae cell concentration, and the radiation characteristics of the microalgae. The latter complicates the optimization of the lipid production protocols as nitrogen deprivation also causes the cells to progressively decrease their pigmentation thus changing their radiation characteristics. This study presents the overall methodology and the effects of nitrogen starvation on N.oculata. The approach highlighted the strong effect of nitrogen starvation on cell metabolism in addition to the increase in fatty acid content of the cells. These effects were quantified by the progressive changes in the average cell absorption and scattering cross-sections caused by modifications in specific chlorophyll and carotenoid concentrations, cell size distribution.
Ananth Iyer
Faculty: Project Co-PI
Does the nitrogen starvation approach cause any undesirable side effects that then have to be managed or is it a benogn process ?
Razmig Kandilian
Thank you for the question, nitrogen starvation does not cause any adverse effect. There are no undesirable byproducts to this process. The byproducts are the same as they are for nitrogen replete microalgae cultivation all of which can be valorized.
Paulette Clancy
Faculty: Project Co-PI
How is your work different from the previous studies that identified the importance of nitrogen starvation?
Razmig Kandilian
The previous studies (Van vooren et. al. 2012, Converti et al. 2009, Pruvost et al. 2011) have mostly been about varying parameters to see what conditions result in largest lipid productivity. Most of the parameters they varied affected the light transfer in the bioreactor which gave us a reason to believe lipid productivity and light availability and absorption are linked. Our study characterized the nitrogen starvation process in terms of the evolution of absorption and scattering cross-sections of the cells along with lipid productiivty. These radiation characteristics enable us to model the radiation field inside the photobioreactor as a function of time and optimize photobioreactors for maximum lipid production.
The significance of understanding this link is crucial to move from labscale photobioreactors to large scale outdoor ones.
Ranjit Koodali
Faculty: Project Co-PI
Are there examples of other microalgae that can accumulate lipids?
Razmig Kandilian
There are many microalgae that accumulate lipids such as chlorella vulgaris, neochloris oleobundans, Scenedesmus obliquus. What is interesting about Nannochloropsis oculata is we have seen that during nitrogen starvation most of the accumulated lipids are in the form of triglycerides which can be converted to biodiesel by transesterification which consumes less energy compared to the conversion of fatty acids that need to be esterified.
Ranjit Koodali
Faculty: Project Co-PI
Thank you very much for the excellent clarification.
Razmig Kandilian
It is my pleasure to talk about my research. Thank you for watching my presentation and video.
Matthew Yates
Faculty: Project Co-PI
Absorption and scattering of light, at least superficially, result in the same type of constraint on reactor design. Namely, that optical path length should be kept as small as possible. This suggests reactors should be made very thin and transparent. Given the kinetic changes in absorption versus scattering that you measure, do your results indicate other novel reactor designs or operating conditions that may be utilized to obtain maximum lipid production?
Razmig Kandilian
Yes, in fact the purpose of this characterization is to use the radiation characteristics and obtain a value for the optical thickness that results in the largest lipid productivity.
Preliminary analysis suggests that there is in fact an optimum optical thickness that results in maximum lipid productivity. This optical thickness is determined in a photobioreactor by both the cell concentration present and their absorption and scattering characteristics. The latter two along with the optical path length (thickness of the reactor in our example) are important characteristics of the reactor that can be optimized.
Therefore, given the knowledge of the radiation characteristics, the cell concentration and the optical pathlength can be adjusted to result in optimum conditions for maximum lipid production.
As a side note, scattering of light by microalgae are for the most part in the forward direction (due to their size compared to the wavelength of visible light) so it serves to diffuse the light further into the photobioreactor and is not a great source of light extinction.
Ian Harrison
Faculty: Project PI
Do the algae eventually go into some kind of stasis when starved of N such that their growth or lipid production eventually tails off? What limits the maximum cell size?
Razmig Kandilian
Yes in fact they do. They lipid content in the cells plateaus. In addition, as they lose their pigments they lose the ability to perform photosynthesis and at some point they start to consume their lipids to maintain the biomass or die. We did not extend our experiments to this regime as is not interesting for industrial lipid production. The first week of cultivation is when the largest lipid accumulation occurs and when we expect to see highest lipid productivity.
As for the cell size, I have worked two different strains of Nannochloropsis oculata and one of them was on average 2.5 micrometer and the other (featured in this work) was approximately a micrometer larger in diameter. Each species and each strain has a distinct size but what we noticed was the size or volume increased as the lipid concentration in the cells increased. This may be due to the different densities of each of the specific components of the cell.
Ian Harrison
Faculty: Project PI
Thanks for the detailed reply.